Statement by the Market Greens ·

More markets!

For too long, Finland's established major parties have pursued pro-business policies: protecting industries and companies through business subsidies.

We want to promote better pro-market policies that make it easier for new players and healthy competition to emerge.

This does not mean blindly deregulating markets, but guiding them to solve real problems so that they better serve people and the environment.

Politicians' job is to set goals and ground rules for markets. If pollution, congestion and damage to nature have no price, we get too much of them.

Putting the right price on harmful impacts guides businesses and consumers towards better choices. At the same time, acting responsibly becomes a competitive advantage.

That is why we want more markets where they are needed:

  • public procurement

  • transport

  • cities

  • the land-use sector

A joint statement by the Market Greens, which I contributed to.

Market Greens campaign graphic: More markets. Less inefficiency.

Read the original statement on the Market Greens website →

Rigid politics, economic inefficiency and the protection of established players have brought Finland to a standstill. It is time to harness market mechanisms to tackle economic, climate and urban challenges more effectively.

The market economy solves the problems we set it

The market economy is an effective tool, but market rules determine what that effectiveness achieves. We currently use markets well in some respects, but in others at the expense of the common good. Some players also remain structurally shielded from genuinely competitive markets. We want to change this!

For too long, people who support markets in Finland have had only poor options to choose from. The established parties have pursued pro-business policies: protecting incumbents' interests and keeping inefficient businesses on life support. This is not support for healthy market competition. It obstructs new entrants and prevents the economic renewal known as creative destruction.

We want to advance better pro-market policies that make it easier for new players and healthy competition to emerge. This does not mean blindly deregulating markets, but directing them towards solving the right problems.

This means putting a price on harms such as pollution, pressure on nature, congestion and the occupation of public urban space. Pricing externalities correctly gives businesses and consumers a continuous incentive to reduce harm. Markets often guide behaviour more effectively than centralised political micromanagement. Politicians should set goals and rules for markets while leaving competition and innovation room to find the best solutions.

At the same time, we correct an existing injustice: when those causing harm pay more, the burden on other taxpayers falls. Responsibility becomes a financial advantage. This opens markets to sustainable businesses and new companies.

The Greens are Finland's leading market-liberal party. Our economic policy does not rest on protecting old structures or particular business groups. We defend open competition, new entrants and functioning markets.

Unlike the major parties on the right and left, we have no ties to old structures or companies that we need to protect. Those ties are reflected in the established major parties' reluctance to cut business subsidies that preserve the status quo.

We, the Market Greens, want more markets where the political left's excessive detail in regulation and the political right's pro-business approach fail. We also want to build markets that better serve people and the environment.

We propose five measures to address this:

Demand 1 / 5

More markets in transport

Taxpayers currently subsidise regional flights by tens of millions of euros each year. This creates problems including unnecessary climate emissions and money wasted on half-empty aircraft. It also distorts competition between transport modes and treats cities unequally: some regional flights receive only partial subsidies, while the state pays the full cost of others.

The role of government is not to sustain demand for a transport mode that cannot survive commercially. It is to ensure that different modes compete under rules that are as fair as possible.

All modes, from cars and trains to aircraft, should be based on fair competition that accounts for the harm each causes. The choice should belong to the individual, not the state. Anyone wishing to fly from Jyväskylä to Helsinki can do so at their own expense, without the public paying.

Demand 2 / 5

More markets in public procurement

The public sector is an enormous buyer in Finland. Public procurement is worth billions of euros each year and has a major impact on the economy and how markets function. Done well, it increases competition, helps companies grow, improves services and steers markets towards more responsible solutions. Done badly, it locks the public sector into incumbent suppliers, raises costs and shuts out challengers.

According to the Finnish Competition and Consumer Authority, public procurement has "alarmingly little competition": around half of tenders receive at most three bids, and more than a thousand procurements each year receive just one. Limited competition weakens the public sector's negotiating position and increases the risk of excessive costs. Genuine competition helps ensure that contracts go to companies capable of delivering high-quality services responsibly and cost-effectively.

Too often, public procurement is designed so that only large, established players can succeed. Contracts are too large, reference requirements favour incumbent suppliers, and tenders prescribe solutions so precisely that companies have no room to innovate. This is not a genuine market economy, but merely the appearance of competition.

The Market Green solution is to open public procurement to more genuine competition. Contracts should be sensibly divided into lots so that small and medium-sized enterprises and growth companies can participate. Unnecessary reference and turnover requirements should be relaxed where they are not genuinely relevant. The public sector should engage in more market dialogue before tendering to avoid inadvertently tailoring contracts to one incumbent supplier.

Procurement must also reward responsible suppliers. The public sector should look beyond the lowest purchase price to quality, life-cycle costs, impact and responsibility, using market-based approaches.

Demand 3 / 5

More markets in urban transport

Road congestion has long been a growing problem, particularly in the Helsinki metropolitan area. A city-centre tunnel costing up to €1.4 billion has therefore been proposed, which would significantly increase the area's municipal tax rate. It would have to be funded through taxes: financing it through user fees would make it so expensive that hardly anyone would use it (a 2013 estimate was €7.50 per journey).

Instead of excavating a billion-euro tunnel through bedrock, it is far easier and more sensible to tackle congestion using market mechanisms. Dynamic road pricing lets road users choose the best solution for themselves. You can choose to drive during the morning commute if you consider it worth a road charge of a few euros. In return, you get significantly smoother traffic and faster journeys as some people switch to other modes. Some trips will also not be made if people do not consider them worth a few euros.

Experience with road pricing has been so positive that no city which introduced it has subsequently abandoned it. Stockholm, for example, trialled road pricing for seven months in 2006. The charges reduced congestion and improved air quality, and city residents voted in a referendum to make them permanent the following year. Drivers also value smoother traffic so highly that, once they have experienced the benefits, they have not wanted to return to the old system.

Let us make road pricing possible here too, giving growing cities more tools for sensible, market-based transport policy.

Demand 4 / 5

More markets in urban space

Finnish cities typically require developers to provide a certain number of parking spaces in new buildings. In practice, these minimum parking requirements hide the true price of parking from the market.

Building a parking space in central Helsinki costs tens of thousands of euros. That cost is hidden in housing and commercial property prices, and drivers often do not pay it directly. The result is a market distortion: public urban space and expensive construction are subsidised for motorists at others' expense, including those who cycle or use public transport.

Minimum parking requirements also raise housing costs. Requiring every new residential building to include a fixed number of spaces regardless of residents' actual needs raises construction costs, which ultimately feed into housing prices. At worst, building a parking garage costs residents more than they would be willing to pay for a space on the open market.

Better results would come from letting markets determine the number of parking spaces. Removing minimum requirements would let developers and residents decide how much parking is needed. Areas with good public transport would have fewer spaces and cheaper housing. Where cars are essential, the market would supply spaces according to demand. Urban space would be used more efficiently, housing would become cheaper and travel choices would be guided by the market.

Removing minimum parking requirements shows how eliminating market distortions can create a city that is both more economically efficient and more humane, while reducing unnecessarily detailed regulation.

“I have seen first-hand how businesses change their behaviour when incentives are right. Politics must establish rules under which the most efficient and responsible players can succeed.”

Susanna Sielo

Demand 5 / 5

More markets in forestry and agriculture

The failure of climate policy has created poor incentives and left taxpayers paying for the consequences of harmful practices in established industries.

This particularly concerns the land-use sector and its contribution to climate targets. Emissions from forests and agricultural land have become a major problem. Action now requires the political will and courage to improve the situation.

In practice, this means that the costs of climate emissions caused by the forest industry, for example, are falling on taxpayers. Above all, this creates a serious incentive problem: when taxpayers foot the bill, the forest industry has no financial incentive to change its practices.

With solutions left to political horse-trading and lobbyists, effective measures stall and Finland's carbon sinks erode. The land-use sector must be brought into a rigorous, market-based emissions trading system. A clear market price for the carbon balance would prompt markets to respond and find the most sensible solutions. It would also bring reality closer to the forest industry's claims of practising the world's best forest management.

Let us create markets for carbon sequestration and nature restoration. Giving carbon storage a monetary value can provide forest owners and rural entrepreneurs with new income from environmentally sustainable solutions. Harmful and inefficient drainage of peatland forests would become unprofitable, while continuous-cover forestry would become profitable without complex subsidy schemes. Efficient carbon sequestration would become a new, productive business. When polluters pay, others no longer have to cover the cost from their own pockets.

Markets deliver more efficient and fairer solutions

We do not believe in an unregulated Wild West, but neither do we believe in central planning or politicians knowing everything, particularly about which tools to use. Giving activities that cause significant harm, such as the fossil economy or excessive consumption of urban space, a real market price finally gets incentives right.

When markets handle pricing, others no longer get the bill for irresponsible behaviour, and we end the current robbery in which irresponsibility is subsidised from other people's pockets. The polluter pays, while those who cause little harm save money. That is both fair and economically efficient.

Politicians should set the framework and rules, leaving markets to handle the rest dynamically and efficiently. A well-functioning market economy is a tool for building a more sustainable, prosperous and humane society. Market mechanisms are not a magic wand, but we are currently failing to make enough use of their potential.

Join us in building a better market economy in Finland, one that does more for our shared wellbeing!

Originally published on the Market Greens website: More markets!

← Back to the blog